The Top Ten Connections Between
NIST and Nano-Thermites
KEVIN R. RYAN
July 2, 2008
"Was the steel tested for explosives or thermite residues?
. . . NIST did not test for the residue of these compounds
in the steel."
-- NIST Responses to FAQs, August 2006
The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
has had considerable difficulty determining a politically correct sequence of
events for the unprecedented destruction of three World Trade Center (WTC)
buildings on 9/11 (Douglas 2006, Ryan 2006, Gourley 2007).
But despite a number of variations in NIST’s story,
it never considered explosives or pyrotechnic materials
in any of its hypotheses.
This omission is at odds with several other striking facts;
first, the requirement of the national standard for fire investigation
(NFPA 921), which calls for testing related to thermite
and other pyrotechnics,
and second, the extensive experience NIST investigators
have with explosive and thermite materials.
One of the most intriguing aspects of NIST’s diversionary posture
has been their total lack of interest in explosive or pyrotechnic features in
their explanations. Despite the substantial evidence for the use of explosives
at the WTC (Jones 2006, Legge and Szamboti 2007), and the extensive expertise
in explosives among NIST investigators (Ryan 2007), explosives were never
considered in the NIST WTC investigation. Only after considerable criticism of
this fact did NIST deign to add one small disclaimer to their final report on
the towers, suggesting they found no evidence for explosives.
The extensive evidence that explosives were used at the WTC
includes witness testimony (MacQueen 2006),
overwhelming physical evidence
(Griffin 2005, Hoffman et al 2005, Jones and Legge et al 2008)
and simple common sense
There is also substantial evidence that aluminothermic
(thermite) materials were present at the WTC (Jones 2007),
and the presence of such materials can explain the existence
of intense fire where it would not otherwise have existed.
Additionally, despite agreement from all parties that
the assumed availability of fuel allowed for the fires
in any given location of each of the WTC buildings
to last only twenty minutes (NIST 2007),
the fires lasted much longer and produced extreme temperatures
(Jones and Farrer et al 2008).
These inexplicable fires are a reminder that the WTC
buildings were not simply demolished, but were demolished in a deceptive way.
That is, the buildings were brought down so as to make it look like the impact
of the planes and the resulting fires might have caused their unprecedented,
symmetrical destruction. Therefore, shaped charges and other typical explosive
configurations were likely used, but there was more to it than that. Those
committing the crimes needed to create fire where it would not have existed
otherwise, and draw attention toward the part of the buildings where the planes
impacted (or in the case of WTC 7, away from the building altogether).
This was most probably accomplished through the use of
nano-thermites, which are high-tech energetic materials made by mixing ultra
fine grain (UFG) aluminum and UFG metal oxides;
usually iron oxide, molybdenum oxide or copper oxide,
although other compounds can be used (Prakash 2005, Rai 2005).
The mixing is accomplished by adding these reactants to a liquid solution
where they form what are called “sols”, and then adding a gelling
agent that captures these tiny reactive combinations in their intimately
mixed state (LLNL 2000).
The resulting “sol-gel” is then dried to form a porous
reactive material that can be ignited in a number of ways.
The high surface area of the reactants within energetic
sol-gels allows for the far higher rate of energy release than is seen in
“macro” thermite mixtures,
making nano-thermites “high explosives” as
well as pyrotechnic materials (Tillotson et al 1999).
are often called energetic nanocomposites,
metastable intermolecular composites
(MICs) or superthermite (COEM 2004, Son et al 2007),
and silica is often used to create the porous,
structural framework (Clapsaddle et al 2004, Zhao et al 2004).
Nano-thermites have also been made with RDX (Pivkina et al 2004),
and with thermoplastic elastomers (Diaz et al 2003).
But it is important to remember that, despite the name,
nano-thermites pack a much bigger punch than typical
It turns out that explosive, sol-gel nano-thermites were
developed by US government scientists, at Lawrence Livermore National
Laboratories (LLNL) (Tillotson et al 1998, Gash et al 2000, Gash et al 2002).
These LLNL scientists reported that --
“The sol-gel process
is very amenable to dip-, spin-, and spray-coating technologies to coat
surfaces. We have utilized this property to dip-coat various substrates to make
sol-gel Fe,O,/ Al / Viton coatings. The energetic coating dries to give a nice
adherent film. Preliminary experiments indicate that films of the hybrid
material are self-propagating when ignited by thermal stimulus”
(Gash et al 2002).
The amazing correlation between floors of impact and floors
of apparent failure suggests that spray-on nano-thermite materials may have
been applied to the steel components of the WTC buildings, underneath the
upgraded fireproofing (Ryan 2008).
This could have been done in such a way that
very few people knew what was happening.
The Port Authority’s engineering
consultant Buro Happold, helping with evaluation of the fireproofing upgrades,
suggested the use of “alternative materials” (NIST 2005).
materials could have been spray-on nano-thermites substituted for intumescent
paint or Interchar-like fireproofing primers (NASA 2006).
It seems quite possible that this kind of substitution
could have been made with few people noticing.
Regardless of how thermite materials were installed in the
WTC, it is strange that NIST has been so blind to any such possibility. In
fact, when reading NIST’s reports on the WTC, and its periodic responses to
FAQs from the public, one might get the idea that no one in the NIST
organization had ever heard of nano-thermites before. But the truth is, many
of the scientists and organizations involved in the NIST WTC investigation were
not only well aware of nano-thermites, they actually had considerable
connection to, and in some cases expertise in, this exact technology.
Here are the top ten reasons why nano-thermites, and
nano-thermite coatings, should have come to mind quickly for the NIST WTC
NIST was working with LLNL to test and characterize these
sol-gel nano-thermites, at least as early as 1999 (Tillotson et al 1999).
Forman Williams, the lead engineer on NIST’s advisory
committee, and the most prominent engineering expert for Popular
Mechanics, is an expert on the deflagration of energetic materials and the
“ignition of porous energetic materials”
(Margolis and Williams
1996, Telengator et al 1998, Margolis and Williams 1999).
Nano-thermites are porous energetic materials.
Additionally, Williams’ research partner,
Stephen Margolis, has presented at conferences where nano-energetics are
the focus (Gordon 1999). Some of Williams’ other colleagues at the
University of California San Diego, like David J. Benson, are also experts
on nano-thermite materials (Choi et al 2005, Jordan et al 2007).
Science Applications International (SAIC) is the DOD and
Homeland Security contractor that supplied the largest contingent of
non-governmental investigators to the NIST WTC investigation. SAIC has
extensive links to nano-thermites, developing and judging nano-thermite
research proposals for the military and other military contractors, and
developing and formulating nano-thermites directly (Army 2008, DOD 2007).
SAIC’s subsidiary Applied Ordnance Technology has done research on the
ignition of nanothermites with lasers (Howard et al 2005).
In an interesting coincidence, SAIC
was the firm that investigated the 1993 WTC bombing,
boasting that -- “After
the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, our blast analyses produced tangible
results that helped identify those responsible (SAIC 2004).”
And the coincidences with this company don’t stop there,
as SAIC was responsible for
evaluating the WTC for terrorism risks in 1986 as well (CRHC 2008).
SAIC is also linked to the late 1990s security upgrades at the WTC,
the Rudy Giuliani administration, and the anthrax incidents after 9/11,
through former employees Jerome Hauer and Steven Hatfill.
Arden Bement, the metallurgist and expert on fuels and
materials who was nominated as director of NIST by President George W.
Bush in October 2001, was former deputy secretary of defense, former
director of DARPA’s office of materials science,
and former executive at TRW.
Of course, DOD and DARPA are both
leaders in the production and use of nano-thermites (Amptiac 2002, DOD 2005).
And military and aerospace contractor TRW has had a long collaboration with
NASA laboratories in the development of energetic materials that are components
of advanced propellants,
like nano-gelled explosive materials (NASA 2001).
TRW Aeronautics also made fireproof composites and high performance elastomer
formulations, and worked with NASA to make energetic aerogels.
Additionally, Bement was a professor at Purdue and MIT.
Purdue has a thriving program for nano-thermites (Son 2008).
And interestingly, at MIT’s Institute for Soldier Nanotechnology,
we find Martin Z. Bazant, son of notable “conspiracy debunker”
Zdenek P. Bazant (MIT 2008),
who does research on granular flows, and the electrochemical
interactions of silicon.
Zdenek P. Bazant is interested in nanocomposites as well
(Northwestern 2008), and how they relate to naval warfare (ONR 2008).
MIT was represented at nano-energetics conferences as early as 1998
Bement was also a director at both
Battelle and the Lord Corporation.
Battelle (where the anthrax was made) is an
organization of “experts in fundamental technologies from the five
National Laboratories we manage or co-manage for the US DOE.”
Battelle advertises their
specialization in nanocomposite coatings (Battelle 2008).
The Lord Corporation also makes high-tech coatings
for military applications (Lord 2008). In 1999,
Lord Corp was working with the Army and NASA on “advanced polymer
composites, advanced metals, and multifunctional materials” (Army 1999).
Hratch Semerjian, long-time director of NIST’s chemical
division, was promoted to acting director of NIST in November 2004,
and took over the WTC investigation until the completion
of the report on the towers.
Semerjian is closely linked to former NIST employee Michael Zachariah,
perhaps the world’s most prominent expert on nano-thermites
(Zachariah 2008). In fact, Semerjian and Zachariah co-authored ten papers
that focus on nano-particles made of silica,
ceramics and refractory particles.
Zachariah was a major player in the Defense University
Research Initiative on Nanotechnology (DURINT),
a groundbreaking research effort for nano-thermites.
NIST has a long-standing partnership with NASA for the
development of new nano-thermites and other nano-technological materials.
In fact, Michael Zachariah coordinates this partnership (CNMM 2008).
In 2003, two years before the NIST WTC report was issued,
the University of Maryland College Park (UMCP) and NIST signed a
memorandum of understanding to develop nano-technologies like
nano-thermites (NIST 2003). Together, NIST and UMCP have done much work
on nano-thermites (NM2 2008).
NIST has their own Center for Nanoscale Science and Technology
(CNST 2008). Additionally, NIST’s Reactive Flows Group did
research on nanostructured materials and high temperature reactions
in the mid-nineties (NRFG 1996).
Richard Gann, who did the final editing of the NIST WTC
report, managed a project called “Next-Generation Fire Suppression
Technology Program”, both before and after 9/11. Andrzej Miziolek,
another of the world’s leading experts on nano-thermites (Amptiac 2002),
is the author of “Defense Applications of Nanomaterials”,
and also worked on Richard Gann’s fire suppression project (Gann 2002).
Gann’s project was sponsored by DOD’s
Strategic Environmental Research and Development
Program (SERDP), an organization that sponsored a number of LLNL’s
nano-thermite projects (Simpson 2002, Gash et al 2003).
As part of the Federal Laboratory Consortium for
Technology Transfer, NIST partners with the Naval Surface Warfare Center
at Indian Head (NSWC-IH) on Chemical Science and Technology (FLCTT 2008).
NSWC-IH is probably the most prominent US center for nano-thermite
technology (NSWC 2008). In 1999, Jan Puszynski, a scientist working for
the DURINT program, helped NSWC-IH design a pilot plant to produce
nano-size aluminum powder.
It was reported that “At that time, this was [the] only reliable
source of aluminum nanopowders in the United States” (SDSMT 2001),
however, private companies like Argonide and
Technanogy were also known to have such capabilities.
Among an interesting group of
contractors that NSWC-IH hired in 1999 were SAIC, Applied Ordnance, Battelle,
Booz Allen Hamilton, Mantech, Titan, Pacific Scientific Energetic (see below),
and R Stresau Laboratories for “demolition materials” (NSWC 2000).
A tragic coincidence left William
Caswell, an employee of NSWC-IH, dead on the plane said to have hit the
Pentagon (Flight 77). He had for many years worked on “deep-black”
projects at NSWC-IH (Leaf 2007).
The presence of Pacific Scientific Energetics (PSE) in this
list of 1999 NSWC-IH contractors is interesting because PSE was the parent
company of Special Devices, Inc (SDI). SDI specializes in explosives for
defense, aerospace and mining applications, and was acquired in 1998 by John
Lehman, 9/11 Commissioner, member of the Project for a New American Century,
and former Secretary of the Navy (SDI 2008). Lehman divested in 2001.
With this in mind, it is worthwhile to reiterate that
nano-thermite materials were very likely used in the deceptive demolition of
the WTC buildings, but most certainly played only a part in the plan. However,
other high-tech explosives were available to those who had access to
nano-thermite materials at the time. Like SDI, several other organizations
with links to military, space and intelligence programs (e.g. In-Q-Tel, Orbital
Science) have access to many types of high-tech explosives to cut high-strength
bolts and produce pyrotechnic events (Goldstein 2006). These organizations
also have connections to those who could have accessed the buildings, like WTC
tenant Marsh & McLennan and former NASA administrator and Securacom
director, James Abrahamson.
In any case, it is important for those seeking the truth
about 9/11 to consider what organizations and people had access to the
technologies that were used to accomplish the deceptive demolition of the WTC
buildings. It is also important to recognize the links between those who had
access to the technologies, those who had access to the buildings, and those
who produced the clearly false official reports.
To that end we should note that NIST had considerable
connections to nano-thermites, both before and during the WTC investigation.
It is therefore inexplicable why NIST did not consider such materials as an
explanation for the fires that burned on 9/11, and long afterward at Ground
Zero. This fact would not be inexplicable, of course, if those managing the
NIST investigation knew to not look, or test, for such materials.
Amptiac (2002), Amptiac Quarterly Volume 6, No 1, Special
Issue: A Look Inside Nanotechnology,
Army (1999), Summaries of US Army budget activities, FY 1999
Army (2008), US Army SBIR 08.2 Proposal Submision Instructions
Battelle (2008), Corporate website for Nanomaterials / Nanotechnology,
Jordan, JL, Foley JR, Dick, RD, Ferranti L, Thadhani NN,
McDowell DL, Austin RA, Benson DJ (2007), Equation of State of Aluminum-Iron
Oxide-Epoxy Composite, Air Force Research Lab Eglin AFB FL Munitions
Chartek (now International Paint) is the maker of Interchar,
and they work with NASA
Choi HJ, Austin R, Allen JK, McDowell DL, Mistree F, Benson
DJ (2005), An Approach for Robust Design of Reactive Power Metal Mixtures Based
on Non-deterministic Micro-scale Shock Simulation, Journal of Computer-Aided
Materials Design, Volume 12, Number 1 / January, 2005
Clapsaddle BJ, Gash AE, Plantier KB, Pantoya ML, Satcher Jr.
JH, Simpson RL (2004), Synthesis and Characterization of Mixed Metal Oxide
Nanocomposite Energetic Materials, LLNL Report UCRL-PROC-204118
CNMM (2008), NIST/NASA Center for Nano Manufacturing and Metrology
CNST (2008), NIST Center for Nanoscale Science and
COEM (2004), Advanced Energetic Materials, Committee on
Advanced Energetic Materials and Manufacturing Technologies, National Research
Council, The National Academies Press, online book available at --
CRHC (1986), Cooperative Research History Commons, Context
of '(Mid-1986): Report Rates Vulnerability of Public Areas of WTC to Terrorist
Attack as ‘Very High’'
Diaz E, Brousseau P, Ampleman G, Prudhomme RE (2003),
Polymer Nanocomposites from Energetic Thermoplastic Elastomers and Alexâ, Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics 28,
DOD (2005), US Defense Nanotechnology Research and
Development Programs, Department of Defense Director, Defense Research and
Engineering, Executive Summary, May 2005,
DOD (2007), US Department of Defense, Annual Report on
Cooperative Agreements and Other Transactions Entered into during Fiscal Year
2006 Under 10 USC 2371
Douglas, Eric (2006), The NIST WTC Investigation--How Real
Was The Simulation?: A review of NIST NCSTAR 1, J 9/11 Studies,
FLCTT (2008), Federal Laboratory Consortium for Technology
Gann RG (1997), Next-Generation Fire Suppression Technology
Program (NGP): A Status Report, Halon Options Technical Working Conference,
6-8 May 1997
Gann RG (2002), FY2001 Annual Report Next Generation Fire
Suppression Technology Program (NGP), NIST Technical Note 1445, Building and
Fire Research Laboratory
Gash AE, Simpson RL, Tillotson TM, et al (2000), Making
Nanostructured Pyrotechnics in a Beaker, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
(LLNL) UCRL-JC-137593, accessed online16 February 2008,
Gash AE, Simpson RL, Satcher JH (2002), Energetic
Nanocomposites with Sol-gel Chemistry: Synthesis, Safety, and Characterization,
Gash A, Barbee T, Simpson R, Satcher J,.Walton C (2003),
Environmentally Benign Stab,
Detonators, LLNL Report UCRL-TR-201628
Goldstein S (2006), Exploding into Space: Explosive Ordnance
for Space Systems, Crosslink – The Aerospace Corporation
Gordon (1998), Gordon Research Conference on Energetic
Materials, June 1998
Gordon (1999), Gordon Research Conference on Energetic Materials,
Gourley J (2007), Appeal Filed with NIST, Pursuant to
Earlier Request for Correction, J 9/11 Studies, December 2007
Griffin, DR (2005), The Destruction of the World Trade
Center: Why the Official Account Cannot Be True, 911Review.com
Howard SL; Morris JB; Beyer RA; Hamlin SJ; Martin J; Burke
GC; Doris T; Laser initiation thresholds of a green aluminum/molybdenum-
trioxide metastable intermolecular composite and other pyrotechnics,
Proceedings of SPIE,
Jones SE, Farrer J, Jenkins GS, Legge F, et al (2008)
Extremely High Temperatures During the World Trade Center Destruction,
J 9/11 Studies,
Jones SE, Legge FM, Ryan KR, (2008) Fourteen Points of
Agreement with Official Government Reports on the World Trade Center
Destruction, The Open Civil Engineering Journal, Volume 2 Issue 1
Jones SE (2006), Why Indeed Did the WTC Buildings Completely
Collapse?, J 9/11 Studies, September 2006
Jones S E, (2007), Revisiting 9/11/2001--Applying the
Scientific Method, J 9/11 Studies,
Leaf (2007), The Leaf, White Oak Laboratory Alumni Assoc,
Inc, Summer 2007, p 5
Legge F (2007), The Twin Towers and Common Sense, J 9/11
Studies, February 2007,
Legge F, and Szamboti, T (2007), 9/11 and the Twin Towers:
Sudden Collapse Initiation was Impossible, J 9/11 Studies, December 2007 (
LLNL (2000), Science and Technology Review, October 2000,
Nanoscale Chemistry Yields Better Explosives
Lord (2008), Lord Corporation website, Coatings
MacQueen G (2006), 118 Witnesses: The Firefighter's
Testimony to Explosions in the Twin Towers, J 9/11 Studies, August 2006
Margolis SB, Williams FA (1996), Effect of gas-phase thermal
expansion on stability of deflagrations in porous energetic materials.
International Journal of Multiphase Flow 22, 69-91
Margolis SB, Williams FA (1999), Structure and Stability of
Deflagrations in Porous Energetic Materials, Sandia Report SAND99-8458, Sandia
MIT (2008), Institute for Soldier Nanotechnologies website,
Dr. Bazant has also been mentioned with regard to
the development of “particles comprising a 'smart gel' that responds to a
change in its environment”.
NASA (2001), Glenn Research Center website page on gelled
See also brief description at the following link.
NASA (2006), Fire-Resistant Reinforcement Makes Steel
Structures Sturdier, NASA website Scientific and Technical Information,
NIST (2003), Announcement of NIST Memorandum of
Understanding with the Univeristy of Maryland, NIST website
NIST (2005), WTC Report, NCSTAR 1-6A,
Passive Fire Protection, p 25
NIST (2007), NCST Advisory Committee Meeting, December 18,
2007, Final Meeting Minutes,
NM2 (2008), NIST and UMCP, Co-Laboratory
for Nanoparticle Based Manufacturing & Metrology
Northwestern (2008), Civil Engineering Department website
resume for Zdenek P. Bazant, "During the last few years,
Bazant focused attention on the scaling of thin metallic films
and nanocomposites on approach to nanoscale."
NRFG (1996), NIST’s Reactive Flows Group website,
Selected Technical Reports
NSWC (2000), GovernmentContractsWon.com, Year 2000
Government Contracts - Defense Department
NSWC (2008), Webpage for Naval Surface Warfare Center –
ONR (2008), Scaling of Energy Absorption in Composites to
Enhance Survivability, Office of Naval Research, ONR grant N00014-02-1-0622,
Bazant Z, Northwestern University,
Hoffman J, Paul D, Star C (2005), 9/11 Guilt: The Proof is
in Your Hands, documentary film available at
Pivkina A, Ulyanova P, Frolov Y (2004), Nanomaterials for
Heterogeneous Combustion, Propellants, Explosives, Pyrotechnics, 29, No. 1
Prakash A, McCromick A., Zachariah MR (2004), Aero-Sol-Gel
Synthesis of Nanoporous Iron-Oxide Particles: A Potential Oxidizer for
Chem. Mater., 16(8):1466-1471
Prakash, A, McCormick AV, Zachariah MR (2005), Synthesis and
Reactivity of a Super-Reactive Metastable Intermolecular Composite Formulation
of Al/KMnO4, Adv Mater 2005, 17, No. 7 April 4
Rai A, Zhou L, Prakash A, McCormick A, Zachariah MR (2005),
Understanding and Tuning the Reactivity of Nano-Energetic Materials, Mat Res
Soc Sym Proc, 2006, Vol 896, pages 99-110
Ryan K (2006), What is 9/11 Truth? - The First Steps, J 9/11
Studies, August 2006
Ryan K (2007), Looking for Truth in Credentials: The
Peculiar WTC “Experts”, Global Research, March 13, 2007
Ryan K (2008), Another Amazing Coincidence Related to the WTC,
SAIC (2004), Science Applications International Corporation,
Annual Report 2004 http://www.saic.com/news/pdf/Annual-Report2004.pdf
SDMST (2001), South Dakota School of Mines and Technology
website, Research Experience for Teachers, Current Projects 2001
SDI (2008), Special Devices Incorporated website, History
Simpson RL (2002), Safe and Environmentally Acceptable
Sol-Gel-Derived Pyrophoric Pyrotechnics, SERDP Pollution Prevention PP-1276
Son SF, Yetter R, Yang V (2007), Introduction: Nanoscale
Composite Energetic Materials, Journal of Propulsion and Power, Vol. 23, No. 4,
Son (2008), Steven Son energetic materials webpage at Purdue University
Tillotson TM, Simpson RL, Hrubesh LW (1999), Nanostructure
High Explosives Using Sol-gel Chemistry, 98-ERD-048, LLNL Laboratory Directed
Research and Development, Annual Report FY1999
(p 8-11 or 181 of 255)
Tillotson, TM, Hrubesh, Simpson RL Lee RS, Swansiger RW,
Simpson LR (1998), Sol-Gel Processing of Energetic Materials, J.
Non-Crystalline Solids, 225, 358
Telengator AM, Margolis SB, Williams FA (1998), Ignition
Analysis of a Porous Energetic Material --II. Ignition at a Closed Heated End,
Sandia National Laboratory, Sandia Report SAND98-8655, November 1998
University of Idaho Magazine, Fall 2002, p 15
Zahcariah (2008), Faculty webpage for Michael Zachariah
Zhao L, Clapsaddle BJ, Satcher Jr. JH, Schaefer DW, Shea
KJ, (2004), Integrated Chemical Systems: the Simultaneous Formation of Hybrid
Nanocomposites of Iron Oxide and Organo Silsesquioxanes, Lawrence Livermore
National Laboratory, UCRL-JRNL-207355